The Peanut Butter Cup flavor is dangerously good. It’s Michael’s honor to the amazing Audra McDonald. It’s like just like a PB cup but in the form of creamy rice pudding. I highly recommend it. We were having a Tony award party and this was the perfect idea, so cute. And Michael has awesome Broadway stories. My order was simple, delivery was quick, and the packaging was careful and themed. Great service!

If you’re looking for the best rice pudding in the city, look no further. The Original Papa Nick’s recipe is a classic for a reason. It’s pure creamy perfection. My favorite, though, is the bold and refreshing Blueberry. We had an office party for LGBT month and this was the perfect and different choice. They even lent us their Broadway memorabilia and decorated the room which was just icing on the cake.

We hosted a huge Halloween bash this year, and instead of a traditional cake, we went with individual servings of this rice pudding. It was a genius move! The owner even helped me pick out flavors that would travel well. The Apple Crumb felt perfectly autumnal, and the customer service made the entire planning process stress-free. They even made me a candy corn flavor. I know candy corn? But it was delicious.

I cannot recommend the Michael’s enough! They truly made my birthday special. I called in a last-minute order, and the customer service was phenomenal, they were so helpful and enthusiastic. The Cheesecake flavor was rich and creamy, and the Blueberry Crumb was a perfect mix of sweet and tart. Five stars all around!