I wish the Coquito flavor lasted all year! I stocked up and it tastes exactly like the traditional holiday drink it was a little spicy, coconutty, and very creamy. The Michaels’s are always so friendly; they truly brighten my day every time I visit. A dessert that deserves a Tony Award! (that one was for Michael LOL)

I was hesitant to try the Matcha Green Tea in a rice pudding, but it was surprisingly delicious and earthy. It did make sense to make it this creamy delight but I was worried it would taste like powder. Not the case at all, it was delicious. Since it’s their Wicked flavor and we were having a Wicked 2 party, the Broadway theme really elevates the experience, and the service is always kind and attentive. A joyful dessert.

We got the Oreo, Nutella, and Original Papa Nick’s for a Saturday movie/game night. Every single flavor was a hit. The packaging was meticulous, and they even called to confirm my pickup time, showcasing exceptional customer service. You can’t handle the Oreo’th & Houston, we have a Nutella problem, so cute!

I’m the cousin and I’ve been eating my Uncle Nick’s rice pudding for years. He brought it to every party and holiday. I miss him so much. My cousin has gone rouge! I don’t know what the hell he was thinking but these are really awesome. I mean it, just so different. I’ve been eating the plain for so long I never thought it could be invented into these flavors. I’ve tried many but the smores is my total fav. Love you cousin, keep up the great inventions!